In the case of CCTV data, where researchers attended sites in person, nearly one in five sites (18%) did not display any CCTV signage. Where signage was present, in more than four in 10 cases (43%) it was rated as ‘poor’ in terms of visibility and content. Only one third (32.5%) of CCTV signage named the CCTV system operator or data controller.
When it was possible to locate the CCTV data controller, the process of submitting an access request was often “problematic” with data controllers “employing a range of discourses of denial” which “restrict or completely deny data subjects the ability to exercise their informational rights”.
Access requests were sent for a range of data, including paper, digital and CCTV records. Requests made three demands of data controllers, including disclosure of personal data, disclosure of third parties with whom data had been shared, and disclosure of whether (and if so how) data had been subject to automated decision making processes.
The research found that obtaining a satisfactory response concerning all aspects of the requests was a relatively rare occurrence. Four out of ten requests (43%) did not result in personal data being disclosed or data subjects receiving a legitimate reason for the failure to disclose their personal data.
In over half of all cases (56%), no adequate or legally compliant response was received concerning third party data sharing.
In over two-thirds of cases (71%) automated decision making processes were either not addressed or not addressed in a legally compliant manner.
Public sector v private sector responses
There were noted variations in how different types of organisations responded to requests. In general, public sector organisations performed less badly than those in the private sector, with 43% engaging in restrictive practices compared with 62% in the private sector.
Requests for CCTV footage were ‘particularly problematic’, with seven out of 10 requests for CCTV footage being met by ‘restrictive practices’ from data controllers or their representative.
While loyalty card scheme operators were ‘generally facilitative’ in disclosing personal data (86% of cases), they did not perform as strongly in providing information about automated decision making processes (only 50% of cases).
Requests made to banks did not yield much information about third party data sharing, with only 30% of responses disclosing this.
Norris said: “In our view there is an urgent requirement for policy makers to address the failure of law at the European level and its implementation into national law.
“Organisations must ensure that they conform to the law. In particular, organisations need to make it clear who is responsible for dealing with requests from citizens, and they need to train their staff so they are aware of their responsibilities under law. They also need to implement clear and unambiguous procedures to facilitate citizens making access requests.”
The Increasing Resilience in Surveillance Societies (IRISS) project is led by the Institute for the Sociology of Law and Criminology in Austria.
Computerworld







Ltd