One of the great success stories of Ireland’s ICT industry must surely be Intel, and its more than 20 year history in Ireland. That was due in large part to one Craig Barrett, the now retired CEO of Intel.
Barrett has said that the days of Ireland attracting foreign direct investment (FDI) may be at an end, due to the increase in competition, largely from the developing world, and mainly from the BRIC countries: Brazil, Russia, India and China.
Speaking to the Irish Examiner at the Irish Technology Leadership Group (ITLG) conference in Cork, Barrett said "You can’t fault the country for trying to be a good place for FDI, but you can say with some certainty that FDI in the future will be more difficult to obtain, therefore you need to do your own growing."
A few years ago, Barrett was part of a think tank that was tasked with finding ways to stimulate the Irish economy as we languished in the depths of recession. Barrett was unequivocal as he said that of the 14 reasons he cited originally to bring Intel to Ireland, only one, our corporate tax rate, remained. That is a pretty damning indictment, but is it true? To quote the peerless Reverend Lovejoy of The Simpsons, "Yes, with an ‘if’. No, with a ‘but’."
Is FDI for Ireland coming to an end? Well, yes. Attracting the kind of FDI that saw the likes of Intel, HP and Dell site major manufacturing bases here is most assuredly at an end. Barrett is probably correct in saying that many of the reasons for citing such things here are indeed gone. But Ireland has come a long way since then, as has the ICT industry. Therefore, the FDI of today is not the FDI of 1989 and so we must look to more recent trends to see what the future holds.
Dell has transformed its Irish operation, for example, to have both a major services presence here and an operations control centre. Accenture has a business analytics group based here, and IBM has steadily increased its presence at it transformed itself away from being a hardware player to a software and services company. Microsoft too has steadily increased its operations here and now boasts an EMEA centre for technology demonstration and proof of concept.
Irish education too has worked closely over the last few years with industry to ensure that more research from academia closely aligns with industry needs. Barrett himself cites the work that EMC is doing in particular with the Cork Institute, and it is indeed a model for others. But the National College of Ireland has also done sterling work with the likes of Stanford University, Microsoft, SAP and more to ensure that its cloud computing centre is a world leader. None of this existed a few years ago, let alone in ‘89. Added to this are the school adoption programmes for ICT companies as developed by IT@Cork, along with the growing popularity of the Coder Dojo movement here, and the situation looks better than at first glance.
Infrastructure has moved on too in two key areas that has seen Ireland progress as a site for ICT companies. Our geographical position on the western edge of Europe has been enhanced by several major connectivity links both to the Americas and to the UK and Europe that means we now have links that facilitate the likes of financial trading where nanoseconds count. Data centres (DC) too have developed to the point where the prevailing wisdom suggests that the Irish climate is just about perfect for major DCs in terms of free cooling. Hence Amazon, Google, Microsoft and Interxion all siting major DC infrastructure here.
In fact, Denis Collins, chair of IT@Cork and business lead or IBM’s global business continuity, DC and cloud services, has said recently that to foster indigenous companies, especially SMEs, we need to offer ‘turnkey solutions’ in data centres to allow them to get started as quickly as possible on scalable infrastructure. While this is a capital idea, I would go one further and say now that Ireland has had a number of global HQ and operations centres established here for today’s ICT companies, such as Facebook and others, that we use the knowledge and experience to tailor solutions as part of any FDI package for any scale of company. We know how to do it.
But to me, there is one critical piece of the puzzle that has not yet been addressed.
When Microsoft celebrated 20 years in Ireland, CEO Steve Ballmer spoke to the press here. I was lucky enough to attend a roundtable session with five other journalists and when tackled about the corporate tax rate, Ballmer highlighted a far more important aspect of being in Ireland. He said that we will never compete with the likes of the BRICs in producing computer graduates, and should not try. But what we can do is more easily integrate such graduates than can the likes of Redmond, Cupertino or Palo Alto, where, he said, they tend to struggle if transplanted direct from Mumbai, Shenzhen or even Moscow.
Our culture is world renowned as we are known for being gregarious, welcoming people. This translates in a business sense to a welcoming and, crucially, nurturing culture. We will likely never produce enough graduates to fill even domestic vacancies, so let’s not try. While we try to ensure that every Irish computer graduate gets a job, we should also ensure that Government facilitates ICT visas to allow the best and the brightest from the BRICs to come here and acclimatise to the global ICT culture, while being productive, before either staying and contributing further to our vibrant industry scene, or moving on to the international centres. We can make a virtue of our culture in the industry context and so build critical ties with the BRICs to ensure that we can ride the wave of progress instead of drowning beneath it.
But we need that action from Government to ensure that people can come here from the other economies to work and develop, cross pollinating as they go, ensuring that Irish computer graduates are exposed to the new ideas, techniques and philosophies that inevitably will come with the best and brightest from other countries.
FDI may not be at an end, but we must adapt to the new era if we are to continue to compete on the world stage.







Ltd