The evolution of the camcorder follows a pattern identical to most electronic gadgets: From bulky and expensive (anyone remember Sony’s Betamovie?) to tiny and cheap. So, where investing in a camcorder would have at one time set you back thousands of hard earned euro and exposed you to the risk of serious back problems in later life, it is now possible to pick up a gadget that can rest in the palm of your hand for a couple of hundred quid.
As prices and sizes of camcorders have decreased, so has their popularity with consumers. These days, there’s a dizzying range to choose from, catering to all levels – from clueless amateur to aspiring director. Here we take a look at some of the issues you need to be aware of if you’re thinking of buying one.
High def or not?
Much of the debate in the industry centres on the question of High Definition (HD). But most of the fuss is actually generated by manufacturers keen to get consumers onto the HD bandwagon so that they will buy HD TVs to watch the footage they’ve recorded in all its glory. There is still some confusion about what HD actually is: As with most new technologies, there is disagreement between manufacturers as to what standard to adopt. One point worth making is that DVD is not, as is sometimes thought, High Definition. The standard that has emerged from the current range of flavours as the leader is 1080i. In effect, this means a resolution of 1080 interlaced lines or 720 progressive lines. When compared to standard TV, which gives you 525 lines in most cases, you can see the dramatic improvement in picture quality that HD gives you. Better still, it’s delivered in 16:9 (widescreen) format, as opposed to the usual TV format of 4:3.
HD ready camcorders
Now for the flip-side: HD is a new technology, and therefore expensive. The Sony HDR-HC3E launched this year, follows up on the success of the HDR-HC1, but will set you back in the region of EUR*1,479. Editing HD video on your PC requires a lot of power, the minimum recommended configuration is 1 Gb RAM and a graphics card with 256 Mb RAM – and a dual core processor isn’t a bad idea either. If you don’t have the hardware to match, there’s little point taking the HD route. The other potential problem is playback. You can’t store HD video on normal DVDs, and the new HD-DVD and Blu-ray discs will be remain expensive for the foreseeable future. HD-DVD players have just hit the market, but will set you back at least EUR*400 – and you’ll need to buy a HD-DVD rewritable drive to write to the discs. The same goes for Blu-ray players and discs. It’s hardly surprising, then, that many are adopting a wait and see approach when it comes to HD video.
The media mix
The other big issue in the camcorder industry at the moment is storage. There are a number of options available to the consumer. Analogue, many will be pleased to hear, is dead. Why is this good news? The analogue process was almost synonymous with a progressive loss of data – meaning picture quality got gradually worse with time. Digital video provides much greater consistency – the information stays as a series of ‘0’s and ‘1’s, without the need of a messy ‘translation’ by your player. Consequently, your footage stays as crisp and clear as the day you shot it.
MiniDV still going strong
This brings us to another area of confusion that needs some clarification. Many of the Digital Video (DV) camcorders on the market are tape-based. This does not mean they are analogue. MiniDV has been around since the mid-1990s, and is probably still the most popular DV camcorder type on the market. They use cassettes (about half the size of a standard audio cassette) to digitally capture from 45 to 90 minutes of footage with a 500 line resolution. The main advantage of going for the MiniDV option is their very popularity – it’s easy and cheap to buy the tapes, and almost any PC with a FireWire connection will automatically detect a MiniDV camcorder (in much the same way that a USB printer is picked up automatically).
DVD to record
Of course, tape is not the only option when it comes to DV camcorders. DVD discs are making inroads into the market, and can record MPEG-2 video directly onto a small (8cm) DVD that can be played on your DVD player as soon as it leaves the camcorder. Hitachi, Sony and Panasonic have all created DVD models – some of which use DVD-RAM, with others using DVD – RW/+RW. A note of caution here: Not all DVD players are capable of playing all formats – check the manual before parting with any money. The latest crop of DVD based camcorders usually provide support for DVD-R and DVD+R (write-once formats) that can read by most DVD players, which will help to keep you clear of the murky and frustrating world of compatibility issues. The good news in the DVD camcorder arena is that their storage capacity is growing, and they are getting cheaper: Samsungs’ VP DC 161, for example, supports dual layer recording (which doubles capacity) and is available for around EUR*550.
Hard disk for the hard road
Another option is camcorders that use a non-removable hard drive (something like what you have in your laptop). JVC considers this storage solution to be the future, at least for its camcorder range. Critics of the internal hard drive approach have pointed to the relative fragility of the system, but Ian Collins, sales and marketing manager for JVC Ireland, disagrees: “We’ve installed an anti-shock system on our models, that senses when the device is dropped and disengages the hard drive to prevent damage”, he said. Whilst video quality might not be quite as good as MiniDV, it’s the ease of use of hard drive models that are proving popular. An hour of recording can be downloaded to your PC in 6 minutes, whereas the downloading process for MiniDV is ‘realtime’ (meaning it will take an hour to download an hour of recording). The latest model from JVC (the GZ-MG505) sports a 30Gb hard drive and will set you back somewhere in the region of €1500.
Horses for courses
So, which format is for you? It depends, of course, on how you intend to use your footage. If you want to write to DVD or Video CD with little or no editing of video, a disc-based camcorder makes the most sense. If you want to edit your video on your PC, the choice is a little more complicated. On the one hand, the format used by tape-based camcorders is more suited to editing than that of their disc-based rivals (MPEG is a great delivery format, but not so handy when it comes to editing). On the other hand, if you go for the internal hard disc option the speed at which you can download footage is far quicker than tape-based camcorders. The choice is yours.
Contacts:
Harvey Norman Store nationwide
Cantec Computerstores
www.canteconline.ie






Ltd