Supporters of open source software have reacted positively to a vote in the European Parliament that paves the way for a limited form of software patenting to be introduced throughout the EU. Larger software companies, as represented by the Business Software Alliance (BSA), are less pleased.
The vote on September 24th accepted a number of amendments to a controversial directive intended to harmonise patent legislation across the EU.
Among the amendments accepted was one which forbids the patenting of algorithms, and another which explicitly outlaws the patenting of ‘business methods’. In the US, where patent law is more liberal than in Europe, companies have successfully patented methods such as the ‘one-click’ online shopping technique, patented by Amazon.com, and hyperlinking.
The acceptance of the amendments, says Ciaran O’Riordan, an Irish member of the Free Software Foundation, ‘will give Europe the patent law America wishes it had. It gives developers the reassurance that if they are creating a program, they will not be infringing somebody else’s patent’.
As a result of the vote, the leading lobby group opposing the introduction of software patents, the Foundation for a Free Information Infrastructure (FFII) changed its stance from opposing the original directive to supporting the wording of the legislation as it currently stands. ‘This is now our directive too,’ said Hartmut Pilch, president of FFII. ‘We must help the European Parliament defend it.’
There is no guarantee, however, that the legislation will become law in its current state. It has to be debated and accepted by the European Council of Ministers before it returns to the European Parliament for final approval. The European Commission, which initiated the directive on software patents, will become involved if agreement between the various legislative bodies cannot be reached.
The progress of the legislation thus far has been accompanied by vigorous lobbying by groups for and against greater protection for intellectual property holders.
Leading the opposition to the idea of patenting software has been the open source movement as represented in this case by the FFII lobby group. Open source advocates in general decry software patents as being of benefit only to large companies and lawyers. A developer writing code, the argument goes, could unwittingly infringe a patent held by somebody else. There is a fear that software patent law could lead to the practice of patent hoarding, where companies buy up access to patents they have had no part in developing and vigorously pursue those they suspect have infringed them.
In practice, large software firms tend to have wide-ranging cross-patent licensing agreements with each other to indemnify their own developers against patent infringement.
Smaller developers, on the other hand, would have to pay for patent licences or go to great efforts to ensure that their code does not infringe existing patents. This, say open source proponents, is wholly impractical for software development.
‘Software already has protection for intellectual property,’ said Braun Brelin, director of technologies for Dublin-based open-source specialist, OpenApp. ‘It’s called copyright which is much more appropriate for software.’
This argument won the backing of the Green Party in the European Parliament and even from some economists from leading academic institutions including the University of London, Stanford University and the University of California at Berkeley who wrote an open letter to EU lawmakers saying that: ‘the proposed directive will provide opportunities and incentives for the construction of extensive portfolios of software patents..[whose exploitation]..will have serious detrimental effects on European innovation, growth and competitiveness’.
The BSA, whose membership comprises some of the largest US software companies, supports the principle of software patents. Its director of policy in Europe, Francisco Mingorance told ComputerScope he was disappointed with the amended legislation. ‘We are in favour of harmonising rules in Europe,’ he said. ‘For that reason we thought the EU Commission’s original proposal was a good one.’ The amended wording, on the other hand, was ‘highly questionable with regard to the EU’s intellectual property obligations’.
He maintained that the current legislation would negatively impact the patents held by many companies that were not strictly software developers. In particular, he said, some large European telecommunications companies would now be drawn into the debate because in some cases ‘half of their patent portfolio would now be worthless’.
17/10/2003







Ltd