Discrimination on the basis of gender has been illegal in Ireland since 1977, but that doesn’t mean all is necessarily equal when it comes to access to senior positions in business.
Just six per cent of Ireland’s company directors are women, and women remain under-represented at senior level across a wide spread of sectors. Among them is IT-according to a recent report published by Cisco, just 17% of those working in the Irish and UK technology sector are women.
Why is this the case? Are women not welcome in the IT sector? Are they not interested in working in IT, or is something else entirely going on?
According to Kim Majerus, managing director of Cisco Ireland, the perception that the IT sector is male-dominated and involves heavy number crunching puts many women off a career in technology. “I don’t think women, and I’ll speak for the young women I’ve talked to and mentored over the last few years, know enough about how diverse and broad the industry is,” she said.
Breadth of industry
“Many of them think that to work in IT they have to be a programmer or a mathematician of some sort, but of course the IT industry has opportunities for women with all sorts of skill sets and desires. I’m not a mathematician by any stretch of the imagination, but I am very creative and I like problem solving. It’s important for the sector in general to do a better job of educating people as to what the industry actually looks like.”
Majerus has worked in the information and communications technology industry for 17 years and under her management, Cisco Ireland has been named one of the Top 15 Places to work in Ireland in 2010 and Top 50 Places to Work in Ireland in 2009. Her company has also received a special recognition award for being one of the top three companies for embracing diversity.
She believes that a particular problem surrounding the issue of women in IT is that there are lingering remnants of gender stereotyping which suggests that men are good at certain jobs, and women at others.
“I think as the workforce becomes more diverse we realise not that men or women are suited to certain roles, but rather that people are good at certain things. There can be lingering stereotypical views that suggest that men are good accountants, and that women are good at marketing or whatever. But that kind of stereotyping doesn’t ring true in reality. I know plenty of women who are great accountants, for example,” she said.
Talent first
Karen Forte, chief information officer and head of services for Allianz in Ireland, agrees. “The stereotypes surrounding the IT sector are that it’s very male-dominated, that you have to be a propeller head, geek or other pejorative term to want to work in it, and that it’s exclusively science or maths-based. But that’s not the case at all,” she said.
“It’s an industry where people have to be very flexible and willing to engage in ever changing opportunities, be they technical or organisational. It’s moved much more away from the technical dimension towards understanding the business needs that can propel an organisation to success.”
Forte has worked in IT for close to 30 years, with 24 of those years spent in the role of head of IT or CIO for a variety of organisations.
“I would suggest that our industry is probably one of the more egalitarian. I started off in a consultancy role with Arthur Anderson in London before it became Accenture, and that was at an interesting time in the late 1970s. Their philosophy was that they would recruit talent, and gender wasn’t really an issue,” she said.
“When I contrast it at the time to professions such as medicine and law, it was much more open to women. Things have improved dramatically since the 1970s in those other fields, but I think IT was further ahead back then.”
Quota folly
Forte would like to see more women in senior positions in Ireland, but doesn’t like the idea of quota-style solutions to the under representation of women.
“I think things should always be based on merit. I’ve always felt that there is something inherently flawed about tokenism, about trying to position people on the basis of quotas. It’s dangerous and sets people up for a fall,” she said.
“I think that the industry is actually reasonably well served with female talent. I was involved with the start up of the Association for Information Managers (AIM) Ireland a few years ago, and I was heartened to see the number of women in senior IT positions where I hadn’t expected it. When you look around, there are quite a number of senior women in IT in Ireland, and that’s evidence that there is a cohort that is willing to take on those challenges.”
A key factor in getting more Irish women to consider a career in IT is addressing the way related academic subjects are marketed to girls in secondary and third level education. “There’s no doubt that women aren’t well represented in the IT sector, so the question that has to be asked is why” said Ida Renaud, principal recruitment consultant with CPL and a 13 year veteran of IT recruitment.
“There are more and more educated women in the workplace in Ireland in general, but the majority of them are in so-called traditional occupations. I think we’re dealing with the legacy of the way gender roles were traditionally approached in schools, where computer science was traditionally seen as a boy’s subject.”
Modern developments
According to Renaud, that perception is changing. “Modern developments like the popularity of social media sites such as Facebook and Twitter are changing the whole perception of computer science in a positive way. We are seeing more and more women coming into the IT sector, but in terms of people in senior positions, women are still in the minority,” she said.
Renaud points out that even within the IT industry, it still tends to be the case that many women work in the marketing and communications end of the business rather than in core areas.
“I think this goes back to the legacy of how computer science was approached in the past in colleges. Women didn’t really look past the idea that a career in IT meant sitting in front of a computer and coding for eight hours a day. That perception was misleading, because it didn’t and doesn’t tell the full story. It doesn’t, for example, show the possibilities of moving past that into consulting and senior management,” she said.
“I can see a little shift in that in the last few years, but in terms of the number of graduates we see applying for our IT roles, we’re still seeing something like 80% men and 20% women, outside the traditionally female-centric marketing and communications roles.”
Dash of art
An interesting development in academia that may make a difference is the creation of computer science degree courses that allow students to mix ICT with arts.
“From what I understand from talking to more recent graduates, these can be classified as arts degrees. That’s a great advantage, because it means that students can study this subject along with things like history or maths. It gives that subject area more scope,” said Renaud.
“The whole social media explosion and the growth in popularity of accessible devices such as iPhones and iPads, the development of mobile applications in general, is where a lot of young people want to be. It’s helping open people’s eyes to the potential of this area.”
Cisco’s Majerus points out that women control large amounts of discretionary spending on behalf of their families, and that IT companies that sell to the public are foolish not to strive for more equality of gender distribution.
Purse strings
“When it comes to buying a computer or a laptop for their kids, or the next technological device for their smart house-and it increasingly looks like we’re going that way-it’s women that are influencing the decisions,” she said.
“The IT industry would absolutely be better off for having more female involvement. They way I see it, if you have a bunch of suits that all look the same, act the same and talk the same, they’re all going to repeat the same ideas. What kind of diversity is that? But if you put a person into that room that challenges the status quo, the leaps and bounds of change and of new ideas are amazing.”
Challenges
There are some obvious challenges that women face in developing careers in a male-dominated work environment, and one of the most significant is the worry that taking time out to have children may negatively impact on their career prospects. It seems, however, that the most significant factor here is the company culture of the employer, and how well prepared it is to facilitate family issues.
“Nobody is saying it’s easy-there are extra dimensions to building a career for women that men don’t face to the same degree. Getting the work life balance right can be tricky, particularly if a women has children,” said Allianz’s Forte.
“I don’t think having children detracted from my career at all. I had great support from the organisations I worked for and the people I worked with. But there was a lot of planning around it and I took the minimum time off, 12 weeks, so there was some give and take. I built my life and my support structures around my kids. I had help from my spouse and my family, and that made it possible.”
“There are other challenges that appear on an ongoing basis, such as handling the need to travel for work-particularly if that’s over an extended period. But video conferencing and other technological innovations are helping to make it less necessary to travel to do business face to face.”
Maternity no barrier
At the managed services company Hibernia Evros, head of resourcing Sharon O’Reilly also believes that maternity leave isn’t a barrier to career progression.
“If one of the women in the company needs to take maternity leave we cover for each other and mind each other’s accounts while they’re away. The workload gets spread out around the company. In modern companies like ours, performance is much more important than anything else,” she said.
O’Reilly points out that Hibernia Evros isn’t typical of many Irish IT companies, as women are particularly well represented at senior levels within the company.
“We’re unusual because we have Caroline Godsil, a female joint managing director, we have a female director in Pamela Farrell, and three of the senior account managers are female. If we go to an event, we’re usually the only girls at it. The industry is undoubtedly dominated by men,” she said.
“But I don’t really think it matters. Why should it? As long as there aren’t barriers to women working in the industry and in this company, there is demonstrably no glass ceiling.”







Ltd