The rock bottom prices of standard DVD players today and the greater affordability of DVD recorders is set to prompt many consumers to finally ditch their boxy VCR player this Christmas.
However, it’s still not quite as simple as that. Potential buyers will still have to grapple with the fact that there are already three major (and incompatible) recording formats for DVDs – DVD-RW, DVD+RW, and DVD-RAM.
There’s also DVD-R (and DVD+R), which can only be written over once, and DVD-R DL, which are double layered disks with twice the capacity of a standard 4.7 GB single layered disc.
Then there’s the emerging category of Hard Disk Recorders or HDD which, offers a great deal more functionality and capacity, although they’re still a fair bit more expensive than DVD recorders.
It may also have passed the average consumer’s attention that a new generation of DVD technologies are set to become available as early as this winter.
This next generation, which promises to be a considerable advance on today’s DVDs, has already generated a format war so serious that the companies behind the two competing formats tried (but failed) earlier this year to agree on a single format.
And for the more technically ambitious, there’s the option of a PC powered by the Windows XP Media Center Edition 2005 operating system, which can combine all the functions of stand alone DVD recorders and Hi-Fis and replace them with one device that handles everything.
Bit of a minefield
This minefield of competing formats and options available has put many a consumer off investing in a DVD recorder, but this is not the problem it once was. The danger of a VHS/Betamax re-run has all but passed, with most DVD and HDD recorders now supporting most of the major formats.
The only exception to this is DVD-RAM which does not seem to have widespread support, despite its advantages. DVD-RAM can be rewritten 100,000 times compared to 1,000 for its DVD- and DVD+ rivals. It also has double sided discs, meaning double the capacity. It features error correction mechanisms that slow down certain functions, but also protect your data.
Compatibility is far less of an issue with DVD+ and DVD- than for DVD-RAM. Making the case for DVD+ is its slightly faster speeds, less time to save and format discs, and lets you edit files directly on the disc. But DVD- has been around longer, is more widespread and slightly cheaper. It also boasts better copy-protection than DVD+. But there’s little difference in quality.
While despairing of the early market confusion surrounding the different recordable formats, most of the major DVD manufacturers by now make a point of offering combination (e.g. DVD and HDD recorders) and multi-format machines (machines that can play the incompatible DVD+, DVD- and, in some cases, DVD-RAM disks).
DVD recorders
So let’s look at what is available, starting with the cheapest. As mentioned, bog-standard DVD recorders have become much more affordable in the last year or two.
A machine with a good brand name, such as JVC or Sony, start at about €250 are probably worth the extra money over the cheapies, particularly as they are more likely to be multi-format. Mind you, we found a Liteon LVW 5006 dual format DVD recorder available from an online outlet for about €200.
For €250 to €300, a Sony RDR-GX210 DVD Recorder can also play both formats, and offers PAL Progressive Scan and an I-link connection for easy camcorder editing. In addition it offers MP3 and JPEG playback.
Depending on whether or not you’re an audio- or videophile, you might want to check out the connections. Although a SCART socket is all you need, you’ll get better picture quality if the recorder has component-video out and in.
HDD/DVD
On the next level are the DVD and HDD combination recorders. These are sometimes called digital video recorders and is the area that DVD makers are focusing most of their marketing efforts.
Quite right, too. Investing in one of these is probably the surest way of avoiding those frustrating compatibility issues with the various DVD recordable disks but also provides a level of performance, functionality and capacity that leaves basic machines well behind. The picture quality is likely to be broadly the same.
Hitachi’s Memory Master range of HDD/DVD recorders, for instance, are able to record and play back DVD+R, DVD +R DL, DVD+RW, DVD-RAM, DVD-R and DVD-RW.
A stand alone HDD recorder allows you to pause live TV and can automatically set chapters intelligently by detecting major scene changes in the programme being recorded. In most cases, recordings are not portable to other devices.
However, some combination HDD and DVD recorders enable you to burn programmes or movies recorded on the hard drive to a rewritable DVD, and usually in a matter of minutes.
Most HDD have at least 80 GB capacity, but 160 or 250 GB is more like the standard these days, according to industry sources. This equates to between 100 hours and 200 hours of content for a 160 GB drive and more than 300 hrs for a 250 GB drive.
Some higher end models come with an electronic programming guide so you can plan your TV viewing to suit your schedule.
Basically, for a combo DVD/HDD recorder, prices start at about €400 for a quality branded machine although you don’t have to go much above €1,000 to get a super-duper one.
At the top end, the functionality and options available is likely to make your head spin. This is very much a market driven by technology and innovation and product features are changing every day, so be sure to do a bit of research.
But if you can’t bring yourself to remove that video tape collection off the shelves of your living room, there’s a 3-in-1 machine available from JVC that combines, HDD recorder, a DVD recorder AND a VCR player.
Format wars: Blu Ray vs. HD DVD
Fears that the split over the format of the next generation of DVD technology could turn into a re-run of the VHS/Betamax war of the early 1980s look set to be realised.
Paramount Pictures, a major Hollywood studio, said last month that it will make DVD movies in the Blu-Ray format as well as the HD-DVD standard.
The move has confused the technology industry, as it is the first major studio to say publicly that it will produce DVDs in each of the two formats, which both promise high definition pictures, enhanced audio and five or more times the storage space on a standard DVD disc. Until now, the big Hollywood studios have supported one format or the other.
Since the breakdown of negotiations between Toshiba, which makes the HD DVD standard, and Sony, Panasonic and others in the Blu Ray group, the battle between the two formats has turned into an all out turf war for market supremacy. Both backers say they will have products on the market by the end of this year.
The studios, retailers, and others had hoped to avoid a showdown between the competing formats because it costs more to make and sell two sets of discs.
Paramount said that Sony’s inclusion of Blu Ray DVD technology in the forthcoming Playstation 3 console was a big factor in its decision.
The Blu Ray format is expected to have greater storage capacity than the HD DVD (50 GB compared to 30 GB for its rival) for but is also more expensive to make. HD DVD is physically closer to today’s DVDs and also backward compatible, making it easier to manufacture discs in existing factories and to make drives that can also read and write today’s DVD and CD formats.
HD-DVD has won backing from Intel and Microsoft, while Dell, Apple, HP and Samsung have opted to back Blu Ray.
Paramount’s call was a big coup for Blu Ray’s backers, and evens out a playing field that was perceived as sloping in HD-DVD’s favour.
Media Center PC – an alternative to DVD recorders?
For the more PC-oriented consumer, a Media Centre PC may well be a more exciting way of despatching off that old VCR to the electronic recyclers.
By combining a powerful PC and Windows technology, the Media Centre can replace disparate entertainment devices such as DVD recorders and Hi-Fis around the home and replace them with one device that handles everything.
The software enables enables the Media Center interface to be accessed through the TV or monitor via a remote control.
The Media Center interface sits on top of the standard Windows XP and a user can switch in and out between the two environments.
Like a HDD recorder, the Media Center PC can be tuned into an analogue TV and can pause live recordings and enable users to schedule the TV programmes to suit themselves using the electronic programming guide.
On the high end Alienware system reviewed in the October 2005 issue by PC Live!, the system will record up to 290 hours of live TV on an average quality setting. At the better quality setting which is pristine, the storage capacity is reduced to a still impressive 170 hours.
The Media Center also offers a standard DVD player for DVD movies.






Ltd