Toshiba to sell off part of its memory business
Toshiba is selling a portion of its Flash memory business, including the SSD business of the storage & electronic device solutions division, to a not-yet-named buyer.
The company, which invented NAND Flash in the early 1980s, said was exploring spinning off its memory business. A Nikkei’s Asian Review said Toshiba had been considering spinning off its semiconductor operations and selling a partial stake to Western Digital (WD), “as it tries to cope with a massive impairment loss in its US nuclear power unit”.
Toshiba said it is giving “full and careful” consideration regarding the assets to be transferred in the company split, so as to “not interfere with the operation of the Memory business” after the transaction is complete.
The move to spin off its memory business is designed to help it grow through investments a partner could make, the company told investors.
Toshiba and WD already co-operate memory fabrication plants, such as the Fab 2 plant located in Yokkaichi, Japan.
Toshiba’s solvency and fundraising ability are presently in doubt because of a $1.9 billion accounting scandal and a huge loss related to the nuclear plant purchase. Last week, Toshiba announced its share price had tumbled 13% after reports that its nuclear power business had lost $4.4 billion.
“Its financial problems were a major drag on the growth of its memory business,” said Sean Yang, research director of DRAMeXchange.
The Nikkei Asian Review reported that Toshiba may sell a 20% stake in the memory business for between $1.77 billion and $2.65 billion, “while retaining a majority stake and keeping the new company in group earnings.”
“Toshiba has positioned the memory business as a focus business where timely investments, accelerated development time and the ability to ramp-up the production of large capacity, highly reliable 3D memory devices (BiCS Flash) are essential to meet growing demand for storage,” Toshiba said in a shareholder memo. “Splitting off the memory business into a single business entity will afford it greater flexibility in rapid decision-making and enhance financing options, which will lead to further growth of the business and maximize the corporate value of Toshiba Group.”
Toshiba plans to hold a special shareholders meeting to vote on the intended split in March; if all goes well, the company plans to finalise the deal by 31 March.
“Although there are still many undecided items, such as the assets to be transferred, which are still under review, and while the company is still considering various structures with a view to an injection of third party capital… the company recognises that some lead time is required to prepare for the [meeting],” Toshiba said.
Toshiba and WD together represent 35% of global NAND Flash production, according to DRAMeXchange, a division of TrendForce. The leading supplier of NAND Flash, Samsung, has a slightly larger share of 36%, while Micron-Intel and SK Hynix account for 17% and 12%, respectively.
Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron are also the three top DRAM suppliers, so their roadmaps for memory products as a whole are much more developed, DRAMeXchange said. By contrast, Toshiba and WD are limited to just the NAND Flash industry.
DRAMeXchange said Toshiba’s decision to spin off its memory business will give it more operational flexibility and stronger fundraising ability.
“For Toshiba and Western Digital, the capital-intensive nature of the memory industry and the volatility of the end market will make their operational challenges more difficult compared with similar issues encountered by their rivals,” DRAMeXchange stated.
In the long run the current Toshiba/Western Digital alliance will enable an expansion in NAND Flash production capacity and increased efficiency in storage product development, according to DRAMeXchange.
“Toshiba wants to put its memory business in a more stable financial position,” Yang said. “Facing mounting operational and competitive pressure, the spun-off entity will be more effective in raising cash to stay afloat or expand.”
From the financial angle, Toshiba’s latest fiscal quarterly report shows that memory sales roughly made up around 15% of the company’s quarterly revenue. However, up to 50% of the company’s operating margin for the period came from the same source, which means memory has become the main profit driver for Toshiba, DRAMeXchange noted.
“The spin-off deal therefore intends to make fundraising less difficult for Toshiba’s memory business, which will need a steady stream of capital to develop and compete in the memory industry,” Yang noted. “As a separate entity, the memory business will be in a better position to make significant changes to its operation and cost structure, making it more attractive to investors. At the same time, Toshiba’s move bolsters its NAND Flash partnership with Western Digital.”
IDG News Service