Cloud storage: Google Drive vs Microsoft OneDrive
Google and Microsoft's rivalry covers all manner of online services and software, here's how the battle for online cloud storage shakes out
19 December 2019 | 0
There are three cloud storage service that most people consider using: Dropbox, Google Drive, and OneDrive. More often the choice is coming down to the latter two. The magic combination of price and the convenience of integration with other Google and Microsoft services make them top choices.
While both services offer the same basic thing—a tonne of online storage at a good price—there are some key differentiators that make each service the right choice depending on your needs.
Pricing and value
The first big difference is what you get for what you pay. Anyone looking for the lowest price for the most online storage should be looking at Google. The company has an umbrella service called Google One that gives you shared storage that works across all your Google services including Drive and Photos. You can also extend the storage to people in your Google Family.
First, there is the free plan with 15GB that all Google Account users get by default. Anyone who needs more storage than that can pay €20 a year for 100GB of storage, €30 for 200GB, or €100 for a whopping 2TB. The latter also gives you 10% back (as store credit) from purchases in the Google Store.
Microsoft’s pricing is a little different. Instead of charging just for storage, Microsoft folds OneDrive into a Microsoft Office subscription. Office 365 Home costs €100 per year, and with that you get Word, Excel, PowerPoint, Outlook, as well as Access and Publisher for PC, and 1TB of OneDrive storage. On top of that, Office 365 Home can be shared with up to five more people in your family each with their own 1TB of storage. Alternatively, you can pay €70 for Office 365 Personal, which gives you Office and a single 1TB of storage.
You can also pay more to add extra storage to your single account. If you wanted 2TB of storage, for example, you would pay an extra €10 per month or €120 per year. That is more than double what you would pay for Google, but on top of the storage you get Microsoft Office. If you are only interested in OneDrive storage then you can get 100GB for €2 a month, but the focus with Microsoft is on OneDrive as part of an Office 365 subscription.
Both services offer good value but for different reasons. If you want the most online storage possible at the best price, then Google is the obvious choice. If you are more interested in integrating online storage with Microsoft Office, then OneDrive is the way to go.
Winner for value: Microsoft
Winner for pure storage amount: Google
When it comes down to search there are noticeable differences between the two and, no surprise, Google has the clear advantage. When you search on Google Drive potential results start populating right below the search box as you type. That is great if you are searching for something with a specific word in the title or early in the content of the document.
Contrast that to Microsoft’s OneDrive search, which does nothing until you hit Enter on the keyboard.
Winner: Google Drive
On the desktop
OneDrive, as any Windows 10 user knows, is built right into the operating system. Once you sign in you can access all your OneDrive files right from Explorer, as well as decide which files you want on your local computer, and which ones can stay in the cloud.
You can do the same thing with Google Drive, via an app Google calls Backup and Sync. Just like OneDrive it behaves like a folder on your computer, and all data is synced with Google Drive online.
Neither service offers end-to-end encryption. This means they do not offer the option to encrypt files on your PC, send them up to the cloud (over an encrypted channel), and then sit on Google or Microsoft’s servers with only you are holding the key to decrypt them.
Instead, your files are sent to the cloud via HTTPS encryption, and then both Google and Microsoft encrypt your files using their own keys. This use of encryption makes it much harder, if not impossible, for hackers to decrypt your data if they ever broke into the OneDrive or Google Drive servers. It does, however, mean that these companies can still read your files, if they want to, or hand them over to law enforcement if they were compelled to do so.
Anyone interested in an E2EE option can either encrypt all their OneDrive or Google Drive files themselves, though that can get complicated very quickly. You can also look at services designed for E2EE, or try utilities like Cryptomator, an open source option that encrypts your OneDrive or Google Drive data.
Hackers breaking into Microsoft or Google owned servers to steal your Fantasy Football game plan is not all that likely. Stealing your account credentials to get at your plans, however, is very possible.
The problem with cloud file accounts is that if a hacker gets the username and password, they get access to everything. OneDrive recently introduced a feature that helps guard against that called Personal Vault.
This feature does not add encryption to your files. Instead, it adds an extra layer of authentication for sensitive files, such as a fingerprint or face scan, a PIN, a code from your authenticator app, or an authentication code sent to email or SMS. Personal Vault does not seem to support security keys just yet—though you can use a Yubikey to get authenticator codes. Users with a free account can add up to three files, while Office 365 subscribers can add an unlimited number up to their storage limit. Once you open your Personal Vault it remains open until Microsoft detects 20 minutes of inactivity with your files.
We would not recommend this feature as a stand-in for documents that should be protected with E2EE, but it is a nice addition.
We are going to call this one a tie. Look, both services work very well, but they work well for people with different needs. If you are all about the desktop and Microsoft Office then OneDrive is the obvious choice. If you like the notion of the Personal Vault then you should also go with OneDrive.
If, however, everything you do revolves around Gmail, Docs, and Sheets then Google Drive is the best choice. Google Drive is also best for those who are purely interested in getting as much storage as possible at the best price.
It comes down to what your needs are. Once you know that, the best choice between these two services becomes obvious.
IDG News Service