Apple pays $60m for iPad trademark in China
Legal battle ends in settlement for fraction of amount sued for
TechLife | 02 Jul 2012 :
Apple has agreed to pay $60 million for ownership of the iPad trademark in China, as part of a settlement with a little-known Chinese firm called Proview that had tried to ban sales of the tablet in the country, according to a local court.
The Guangdong Province Higher People's Court issued a statement confirming the legal dispute had been put to rest. Following the payment to Proview, Chinese authorities transferred the IPAD trademark to Apple.
Analysis
Niall Kitson
TechCentral.ie
Sixty million dollars sounds like a fortune but Apple will consider it a bargain given the sheer size of the Chinese market. For a company $180 million in debt, only total victory in the case would have saved Proview, which is almost certain to vanish without trace. Despite the massive cash injection creditors won't be any mood to celebrate.
The two companies have been locked in a legal dispute to determine ownership of the iPad trademark, with Apple claiming to have bought the iPad trademarks for China from Proview in 2009.
Proview, a PC and display vendor now facing possible bankruptcy, however, argued that the company had never officially sold the iPad trademarks to Apple. The Chinese company filed complaints and lawsuits, demanding that local authorities stop sales of the iPad in the country because of trademark infringement.
The Guangdong court was originally expected to rule on the case. But Apple and Proview were in recent months in talks to settle the dispute, at the initiative of the court.
Apple did not respond immediately to a request for comment. The company's latest version of the iPad has yet to be sold in the country, despite clearing regulatory checks. Analysts have said the legal dispute over the iPad trademark could be delaying the product's sale.
Proview had wanted as much as $400 million in settlement from Apple in order to help clear its debts. Eight banks have taken over Proview's assets and are owed $180 million.
Li Su, the head of the consultancy representing the eight banks, said Apple initially wanted to pay only a few million dollars for the iPad trademark. But over time, Apple negotiated in good faith, realising the dispute would linger in Chinese courts unless a settlement was reached, he added.
"Some may feel that Apple had help from Chinese leaders by spending a lot of effort on public relations," he said, noting how Apple's CEO Tim Cook visited China in March and met with government officials.
"But I think Apple was acting in good faith," Su added. "Apple only needed to pay a small amount to resolve what could have been a major inconvenience," he said.
Su said he did not know how the $60 million received from Apple would be spent.
IDG News Service